Why Children Steal, Hide or Hoard: The Real Story Behind ‘Difficult’ Behaviour

🎧 Listen now on:
Spotify,
Apple Podcasts,
or watch on
YouTube.

If a child keeps stealing food even when there’s plenty, what are we actually looking at? In this solo episode, Andy Baker uses one scenario – a nine-year-old called “Claire” (name changed) – to explore a trauma-informed truth that can change everything:

Behaviour is often a strategy. Not a character flaw. Not manipulation. Not “being naughty”. Often, it’s a learned way to meet an unmet need or manage stress.

The scenario: “Why is she still taking food?”

Claire experienced early neglect, where food was scarce and unpredictable. Now she’s in a safer environment where meals are regular and snacks are offered – yet she’s still hoarding food, stealing from the fridge, even taking food from bins.

Here’s the key insight: carers and professionals often respond with today logic… but Claire is living in yesterday’s logic. What helped her survive before doesn’t switch off overnight, even when the environment changes.

The trap: story-making and confirmation bias

It’s easy to label behaviour: “greedy”, “attention seeking”, “controlling”. But those labels aren’t curiosity – they’re story-making. And once we’ve decided the story, our brains start hunting for evidence to prove it.

Andy calls this out directly: confirmation bias can turn caring adults into detectives looking for proof, rather than supporters looking for meaning.

A simple trauma-informed lens: need – stress – strategy

Andy shares a practical framework used in the Able Target System and in his wider behaviour support work. Under the “lid” of behaviour, you’ll often find:

• An unmet need (something missing or uncertain)
• Stress (fear, overwhelm, insecurity, pressure)
• A strategy (the person’s best available way to cope or gain safety)

In Claire’s case, the unmet need might not be food itself – it might be certainty. The stress might be the fear of scarcity. And the strategy is hoarding, stashing, stealing.

One line that matters:

It isn’t the food today – it’s the fear about the food tomorrow.

How to help: don’t “stop” the behaviour – make it unnecessary

Instead of asking “How do we stop the stealing?”, Andy reframes it:

How do we make the stealing unnecessary?

This episode explores realistic, trauma-informed steps, including:

• Predictability and routine in the stabilisation phase (trust is built through repetition)
• Reducing shame triggers (no scenes, no comments, no humiliation when food is found)
• Safe control (for example, a named snack box or accessible shelf to reduce the panic)
• Risk management over control (we’re not controlling the child – we’re controlling the risk)
• Adding “friction” without punishment (small environmental changes that reduce harmful options)

Why punishment often teaches secrecy

Andy widens the lens across settings: whether it’s food in foster care, pencil-stealing in school, rummaging in dementia, or swapping items in adult care – if we go straight to punishment, we may not reduce the behaviour.

Often, we just teach people to hide it better.

A takeaway to carry into real life

If you want behaviour to change:

• Make the old behaviour less necessary
• Make the new behaviour more available

This episode is for anyone supporting people with trauma histories, behaviours that challenge, or distress-based coping strategies – including foster carers, kinship carers, teachers, parents, and care professionals.

Recommended courses (click to learn more)

Positive Behaviour Support Training (PBS Training)
Foster Care Training
Youth Mental Health Training Courses